When is deviance a good thing in workplaces?

CCE blog

Welcome to the CCE blog
News & opinion_

When is deviance a good thing in workplaces?
By Stephanie Oley

Good ideas are at the forefront of organisational change – which in turn is critical to business survival. But where do good ideas come from, and how can business leaders recognise them as they emerge?

For specialists in organisational psychology, the answer to that question often lies in positive deviants: individuals who just think differently.

Probe the word ‘deviant’ for a moment, and you’d be right in thinking this has negative connotations. After all, deviant workplace behaviour normally refers to issues such as deliberate lateness, repeated failure to complete tasks, or even project sabotage.

But what about deviation at the other end of the bell curve? This results in new solutions to problems, exceptional performance and innovation. Such thinking is called positive deviance. It’s been attributed to solving problems as diverse as public health, criminal justice, employee engagement and conflict resolution.

Positive deviance

Where does positive deviance come from?

Positive deviance was first coined by nutrition researchers in the 1960s. It reached wider audiences in the 1990s with the book, The Power of Positive Deviance, written by former aid workers Richard Tanner Pascale, Jerry Sternin and Monique Sternin. The group described various health breakthroughs achieved from working with positive deviants in disadvantaged communities.

In the early 1990s, their not-for-profit ran out of funding and could no longer engage an expert to advise on food security for malnourished villagers in Vietnam. The Sternins and their team had to get creative. They observed that some local children were better nourished than others, despite being no more privileged. Upon investigation, the Sternins discovered that these children’s mothers were bucking against standard customs. For example, they were adding lowly sweet-potato greens to their rice, or feeding their children smaller, more frequent meals.

When the group trained other families to do the same, child nutrition outcomes improved a staggering 65 – 80 per cent for the village and elsewhere in Vietnam. This approach, of amplifying actions that worked rather than trying to fix what didn’t, was a simple yet radical shift in thinking.

The Sternins later continued their work in positive deviance elsewhere, finding sustainable solutions to other entrenched problems across the globe. These projects have helped improve survival rates for neonatal mothers in Pakistan, boosted school enrolment for girls in Lebanon, lifted employee engagement in various countries, and much more.

Positive deviance in modern business

Look at many innovations in the business world, and you could argue that positive deviant thinking has been a silent hero for some time.

Consider not being able to stream movies or films on demand, had firms like Netflix or Spotify not helped to legalise a formerly-deviant behavior and turn it into a high-value business. Imagine not being able to look up anything online for free, had the founders of Wikipedia not set out in 2001 to make such knowledge open-source, not held in the hands of encyclopedia publishers. Imagine being unsure of the ethics behind your favourite product or service, had deviant thinking not brought about fair trade, anti-slavery acts or ethical investing.

All of this change contrasts with the conservative nature of decision-making at many organisations, where precedent is everything and novelty is considered risky. Sadly, many organisations do not recognise the potential positive deviance has to transform business practices.

One of CCE’s presenters, Eleanor Shakiba, presents various courses on leadership, including The Psychology of Influence and Negotiation Skills for Professionals. Recently, she was running a leadership program in an engineering company. One of the participants said, "The laziest people sometimes have the best ideas". His tone was dismissive, so she asked him how he actioned those ideas. His response was that he just ignored them. This is an all-too-common response to positive deviance.

How to embrace deviant thinking in your workplace

Imagine the potential of a business that capitalised on positive deviance. It would have an energised, flourishing culture. Ideas would be captured in the moment and turned into solutions. Diversity would not just be a concept celebrated on International Diversity Day. It would be woven into the fabric of teams. Meetings would buzz with engaged conversation. Ideas would flow and people would flourish.

If this image excites you, explore the world of positive deviance. Here are five simple ways to get started:

  1. Read The Power of Positive Deviance by Richard Tanner Pascale, Jerry Sternin and Monique Sternin.
  2. The next time someone proposes an 'impractical' idea, explore it instead of dismissing it.
  3. Scan your business for flourishing teams. Pinpoint what they are doing differently to everyone else. Then replicate their strategies and coach others on how to achieve their success.
  4. Speak up when you have ideas that break the norm.
  5. Ramp up your diversity program and review your performance management systems. Check that they actively support those who deviate from the norm in positive ways.

Whether it’s embracing hybrid working modes, removing unprofitable product lines or adopting sustainable practices, fresh ideas can make the world a better place. It's time to learn now, and join the ranks of the positive deviants.

More articles

CCE blog

New tool to unlock potential for University staff

The University of Sydney has launched a sophisticated Career Capability Framework, matching University jobs against skills that can be developed through the Centre for Continuing Education.

Learning beyond your CCE workshop: 5 pro tips

What do our facilitators tell participants who want to keep learning after attending a professional development workshop?

Workplace diversity: more than a box to tick

Companies that embrace diversity can expect better results in myriad ways: cohesive teams, a better culture, and improved productivity.

Power language for women in business

Communication style is a major theme in our Women in Leadership course and, as with many interpersonal skills, it’s one that can be practised and learned by anyone.

8 tips to lift your business writing craft

So, you’ve attended a writing workshop and learned dozens of new skills in one day. But where to focus your energy next?

The role of EAs is evolving

Despite the importance of Executive Assistants (EA), their future in a firm will depend on them having the right skills. Here are the five broad skillsets that ambitious EAs should continue to hone.

Why your reports are always running late

At its core, a business report is the high-level answer to a central question. But why do your reports often come together at the last minute, and how can you prevent this?

Maximise team performance before EOFY

The end of the financial year (EOFY) rush is almost upon us. Budgets are finalised, books are closed, and plans for the year ahead take shape. Amidst this whirlwind, a valuable opportunity often remains untapped: utilising unused development budgets.

The 2 mindset shifts adopted by good business analysts

In business, planning for growth means anticipating where the market is going. Knowing how to tap into this change is where business analysis comes in.

3 common mistakes made by rookie minute-takers

When you record your organisation’s minutes, you are essentially witnessing business unfold before your eyes. But it’s not easy, so here are three common mistakes to avoid.

Is your project racing against time?

Project time management is not just a skill that’s nice to have. It’s a core part of project management. When done well, it can make project managers seem impossibly capable of bending space and time.

How to give scope creep the flick

Scoping a project accurately can be tricky, and the larger the project the more difficult this becomes. However, scope management can be learned.

7 awesome reasons to polish your interview skills

So, you want to start a podcast, blog or YouTube series. Your interviews with interesting subjects should be a major part of this plan.

The 2 great motivators every leader should know about

The recent rise of burnout among leaders serves as a reminder that even those at the top need the right tools to stay motivated. But what is motivation, and how do we maintain it?

Strength in numbers: Essential tools for analysing your business data

When your datasets contain unthinkable amounts of data, then it's critical to have the right skills and tools to interpret this information. In this article, we'll introduce some of them.

How to sound less awkward in English

Quick - what's better than private tuition in English studies? That's easy - a weekly immersion in the topic, surrounded by other keen learners.

Project management: 6 areas you need to master

Running late with your marketing campaign, tax strategy, IT upgrade or other major business initiative? Chances are there’s a project management issue at stake.

How to write better with ChatGPT – and retain your job

Worried that ChatGPT and other artificial intelligence (AI) writing tools are here to take your job? Don’t be.

7 things to know about studying beginner’s Japanese

Spoken by an estimated 130 million people, Japanese is the ninth-most spoken language in the world. Our facilitator shares 7 tips for beginner students to know.

Beat job interview nerves with these presentation tips

Making the right impression during a job interview is tough for any jobseeker. And even if you’re the perfect candidate, your interviewer may not realise this unless your presentation is convincing.

Creating content on social media? Here’s how to stay legally bulletproof

With billions of users now on social media, the last few years have seen a spiralling incidence of fraudulent content. But social media managers can take several steps to stay safe.

How UX is different from UI, and who needs to know?

User experience (UX) is different from user interface (UI), although the two fields are strongly interlinked. Here we explore the key difference, and the professionals who need to master them.

The 12 steps to shaping a compelling UX

User experience is one of the most sought-after skills to have in the modern workplace. The groundwork is laborious, but the results are worth it.

The one tool that’s transformed workplace collaboration

As workplace collaboration becomes more sophisticated, SharePoint is delivering standout efficiencies to teams with the right skills.

How to deal with difficult people

Dealing with conflict often means dealing with difficult people and their behaviours. But what is difficult behaviour, and how do you respond effectively?

7 tips for studying beginner’s Italian

Not sure if you’re ready to take the leap into studying beginner’s Italian? Our longtime tutor, Antonella Beconi, shares her answers to seven commonly asked questions.

Trust building: A key skill for leaders

Business leaders need to actively shape the dynamics of trust over time. Here are three strategies that all professionals can develop to build trust.

5 things to absolutely get right with your Xero file

Doing your own bookkeeping? Stop being a Xero cowboy, and see which of the following five accounting foundations you need to manage better in your file.

Is Lean Six Sigma still relevant?

When they were first developed Lean and Six Sigma started an entire movement in business productivity tools. So where are they now, and does your business still need them in 2022?

Urban gardening for everyday wellness

Creating a personal green zone in the city doesn’t have to take much effort, and the rewards of gardening and nature are well documented.

How to rank better online with a search-friendly mobile website

If you’ve updated your website recently, you’ll know that its underlying structure has a large impact on search engine rankings. But did you know that, increasingly, Google ranks the mobile version of your site–not the desktop version?Here are 6 areas to focus on to achieve a mobile-first site design.

How to write internal comms that get read and actioned

Writing effective internal comms has long been a sought-after skillset. But with 75 per cent of us now working in a hybrid part-workplace, part-home mode (according to Australia’s Productivity Commission),the importance of writing a clear, engaging all-team memo is more important than ever.

Which is that?

One of the questions that grammar course participants often ask is whether to use that or which in a sentence. There are a few simple ways to determine which one to use, so make sure to read our short article on the topic.

3 steps to get better ROI on your social media

Designed to keep us hooked, social media is now the primary tool for content consumption. And to lift the returns on your business’ social media investment, there are three important steps to take.

Is your business embracing next-gen data visualisation?

Modern data visualisation is removing those communication barriers. Tools such as Power BI,Tableau and Tibco Spotfire can simplify, merge, break down or otherwise interpret datasets, using lush graphics to pinpoint the key issues.

What do you think leadership is?

Leadership takes on many forms at the University, here are some resources for you to look at how the University empowers individuals to take on leadership roles.

5 mindset changes that’ll supercharge your business writing

Writing effectively in business is essential to career progression – in just about every industry. Yet all too often, business writing is poorly structured, densely expressed and lacking in clarity.

Bringing your social media inhouse?

If you’re in business, you’re probably on social media. And why wouldn’t you be? Social media marketing achieves wonders for business. You can connect with customers, promote offers, answer questions, demonstrate expertise, and basically show how special your business is, compared to all the rest.

How to get your boss to see your value

Good work should speak for itself but sometimes we need attention drawn to it. The squeaky wheel gets the grease, so if you want to get ahead, learn to make noise, and get the recognition you deserve.

Smarter SEO behind the scenes of your blog

So, you’ve committed to boosting your website’s traffic with a blog that supports your search-engine optimisation (SEO) activities. You have a content plan, some dedicated writers and an optimised Google Analytics dashboard.

Sold! Why an emotive sales pitch wins each time

Picture this: your salespeople are about to pitch to a valuable new prospect. They’ve prepared the sales deck, honed their spiel and cleared their throats.

The most amazing grammar rule of all

The red, long, Australian, lovely flower, the grevillea, is quite extraordinary. Eh? I’m trying to do justice to the beauty of one of the country’s most striking flowers, but something is wrong.

What does a company’s approach to risk management say about its leadership?

Behind every tale of corporate success or failure is a risk that was managed either exceptionally well, or mishandled with devastating consequences.

When is deviance a good thing in workplaces?

Good ideas are at the forefront of organisational change – which in turn is critical to business survival. But where do good ideas come from, and how can business leaders recognise them as they emerge?

Yes, blogging is still critical to your website’s SEO

Does blogging boost your website’s search engine optimisation (SEO), even in this day and age? Especially given the rise of other approaches used to boost website traffic, such as video content, pay-per-click, or acing Google’s algorithms.

5 tactics to get your boss to notice your value

Recognition of your abilities and outstanding achievements is the first step to being seen as a valuable employee with the potential to step into a leadership role.

Engaging with our community

Community engagement is important in sharing the stories we tell about the work we do, and also in attracting support so that we can keep doing this work.

Support USYD philanthropic causes

The University of Sydney is passionate about philanthropy and has over 4,000 causes that you can support in various ways.

5 skills you need to boost your career

Here are the top skills that are constantly in demand by employers.

Workplace wellbeing in times of adversity

As a leader and colleague, how can you show genuine care for yourself, your team and those you engage with in your day-to-day work?

5 great quotes on learning

Life is better with continuous learning in it. But don’t take it from us, there are many great minds that think so too…

How to achieve your work-life balance

Eliminate stressors with these five simple tips.

University history, architecture and tours

The history of the University is very much intertwined with the history of our city, our country and all the personal histories of those who have passed through our halls.

Creating luck in a time of crisis

Real ‘luck’ and success has a lot more to do with optimism and positive psychology then it does with external circumstances.

How to get the most out of professional development training

Plan to get the most out of your learning with CCE and you will increase the chances that you actually will.

5 vital benefits of editing

Learn structural editing, copy editing and proofreading techniques needed to turn early drafts into perfectly finished products.

The benefits of diversity in the workplace

If you want to succeed in business then hiring a diverse workforce is a good place to start.

CCE and the new Chau Chak Wing Museum

The Museum unites the University’s Nicholson, Macleay and University Art collections under one roof, with new research facilities, engaging programs for the public and learning opportunities for students.

How to increase team collaboration in the workplace

Learn different ways to build team collaboration in the workplace.

3 steps to acing Italian with our menu of classes

It sounds like a stretch if you’re just starting Italian lessons, but one day those language skills might take you deep into the world of Caesar and Cleopatra.

7 steps to a more climate-resilient garden

Climate change is prompting us to plant more sustainable gardens, especially in cities. But where do you start? And what will you need to change if this year brings drought, floods, plagues or something else you weren’t expecting?

Planning your professional development

Identifying your professional development goals will help you get the most out of your training time and budget – and guide you on your career path.

How to get your boss to pay for your professional development

Convincing your employer to pay for your course can seem daunting, but don’t be put off. Here are our tips on how to make your case.

How to get involved with University of Sydney without being a student

The University of Sydney proudly offers a range of opportunities, events and activities open to the wider community throughout the year. We have a vibrant campus life well-beyond traditional classroom learning.

5 courses to help you and your business adapt to change

Reflecting back on the rapid changes seen in our workforce, we have picked five CCE courses that will enable you and your team to quickly adapt to unexpected change.

Arts engagement and mental health

What do you take delight in? Is it learning about past societies in cultures? Or coming up with a beautiful turn of phrase?

Our top 5 favourite Ted Talks on learning

The University of Sydney has a long-standing relationship with TedX Sydney and in 2019 the University partnered with TedX Sydney for its tenth anniversary.

5 tips on how to successfully work from home

Working from home is a very different dynamic that can be a bit challenging to transition to, but if done correctly can lead to greater success in your work.

Navigating different personalities in the workplace

As professionals, we are expected to navigate unusual personality quirks and a desire for different air conditioning temperatures with grace.

5 reasons to consider remote training for your team

Remote learning through interactive, online delivery in real-time is a great way to motivate your team and bring them together through shared learning.

Learning for life: the CCE participants who have attended more than 50 courses

People enrol in short courses at CCE for many reasons: to learn skills to enhance their professional career, to become fluent in another language, to develop critical thinking – or simply to keep the mind engaged.

Are you working with a psychopath?

Psychopaths aren’t killers. Not most of them anyway. That’s the first thing John Le Mesurier, trainer on the Managing Workplace Psychopaths course wants you to know.

Getting through your HSC - A practical guide

The HSC is a long journey. We wish you the best of luck for your HSC and in future endeavours.

Why become a Project Management Professional?

While project management experience was once enough to get you hired or promoted, today that’s no longer the case.

Who wants to be an entrepreneur?

Entrepreneurship is everywhere – from the tenfold growth in venture capital between 2013 and 2018, to an explosion in uptake of co-working spaces.

Three HSC study hacks you probably didn’t know (and one you did)

There are universal HSC study tips, and there are personal ones. Like whether you should study alone or in a group, after dinner or before breakfast, propped up with caffeine or with carrot sticks, and more besides.

Myth-busting Gallipoli: five common misconceptions you need to rethink

Few events in Australian history have been so closely examined as the Gallipoli campaign of 1915, and yet no other has yielded so many myths.

Welcome to the age of the 60-year-curriculum

There’s a new way of imagining what continuing education means to us, and it’s called the 60-year curriculum. Actually, this change has been decades in the making.

Frequently asked questions
Find answers to questions about applications, payment, short courses and more.
See FAQs
Contact us
Our student support team can answer your questions about our short courses.
Get in touch
We use cookies to improve your experience on our site and to show you personalised content. For more information about how we use cookies, please read our Privacy Statement.
Back to Top